Thursday, December 5, 2024

As I Lay Dying, I Need A Hero!!

  For our final Hero’s Journey blog post I wanted to use prompt 3, thus arguing for the validity of one of the characters being the “Hero” of "As I Lay Dying". The character that I’ve decided to focus on in this post is Jewel, and by using a connection to a common heroic trope through his "Jewel's mother is a horse" motif, I want to make a case for Jewel possibly being a, if not the Hero of “As I Lay Dying.”  

First off, starting with the motif of “Jewel’s mother is a horse.” From when we were first introduced to Jewel, he’s shown to be a very standoffish character without much attachment to any of the other characters we get a point of view from, and the only thing we see him show much fondness towards is his horse. From what we’ve seen of Jewel, he doesn’t seem to be much of a hero-inclined character, however, by using his connecting motifs as evidence I want to make an argument against that. 


Jewel managed to get his horse by doing work for Mr. Quick, specifically cleaning up the new ground that Mr. Quick had recently put out. In doing this, he ended up unable to do the work he usually does come morning, and Addie covered for him despite not knowing what was going on while Anse was quick to call him lazy. When the results of Jewel’s nighttime escapades are revealed through the buying of his horse, Addie is distraught at being tricked and later Darl finds her “sitting beside the bed where [Jewel] was sleeping, in the dark. She cried hard…hating herself for doing it, hating him because she had to.”


Now, a character who doesn’t really get along with anyone, only cares for his horse, and takes advantage of his mother’s kindness doesn’t seem like a hero does he? However, the plot thickens as we get Addie’s chapter, and the Cora chapter before it. At the end of Cora’s chapter we see Addie say “He is my cross and he will be my salvation. He will save me from water and from fire. Even though I have laid down my life, he will save me.” This seems to be an extremely prophetic statement, and what tends to be a common trend in hero stories? A prophecy. This prophecy can be further enforced when you think about Addie saying “he will save me from water and from fire.” While we haven’t seen anything fire related, Jewel has in fact been involved in retrieving Addie’s body after she fell into the river, thus fulfilling the salvation from water. 


While this is all the major evidence, we have right now from what we’ve read in “As I Lay Dying” so far, I do also want to point out that I believe the more we’ve of Jewel the less of a jerk he’s being revealed to be. Some notable examples of this being when he managed to find some of Cash’s tools that had fallen in the river, as well as when he went to take his horse himself in order to get the mules to carry the coffin. Jewel is introduced as this dislikeable character, who only cares about his horse instead of his mother, and we see him (somewhat) progress as a person to giving up his horse for his mother's sake. And what's another way to say, "to give up"? Sacrifice. And what's sacrifice another example of? A Heroic Trope.

All this to say, from what I’ve explained in this blog post I believe of all the characters we see in this novel, especially the Bundren family, Jewel makes the most sense to be seen as the Hero of this story. 

7 comments:

  1. Hi Gabby, I also believe that out of all the characters Jewel seems most inclined to be the hero. I think it's also interesting how Jewel only has one chapter in the whole book, so most of the events that occur surrounding him are told from outside perspectives. I also think that there's a distinction between the main character and a hero because arguably Darl is more of the main character while Jewel is more of a hero.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree that Jewel is the most "heroic", due to the reasons you stated. However, I'm not sure if he's truly the "hero" of the story, since he isn't exactly who the story is focused on. I think the Bundren family itself is the hero, because the story is pretty much about them and the developments of each one of them that pertain to the hero's journey.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I don't like any of the characters in this story. That being said, I do think that the evidence you provide makes sense for Jewel to be a hero. I agree that Addie's chapter and Jewel's background all contribute to his heroicness, even though he may not be going through a character change throughout the present journey.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Gabby! I also feel that Jewel is the most heroic-like out of all the Bundrens. It is quite a shame that Jewel only gets one chapter. I think it’s fascinating how you connected Addie’s words about Jewel saving her from the water and fire (the river and burning shed) with the common trope of prophecy in heroic stories.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Hi Gabby! I agree, if there were to be one hero of the journey it would be Jewel. He's slowly revealed to be more and more of a good person and he's probably the most selfless out of all the Bundrens. Though he's not the focus of the book, he's the family member with the least "screen time" which singles him out even more.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hey Gabby, this is a really good representation of Jewel as the hero in the book. Perhaps Jewel got one chapter in the book to divert his attention of being the hero in As I Lay Dying. I also find it interesting how Addie said Jewel would save her from water and from fire and he actually did which is some pretty cool foreshadowing by Faulkner. It also feels like everyone in the Bundren family kind of develops the opposite personality of themselves at the end of the journey.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hi Gabby! I really liked your blog because I completely agree that as you said, Jewel's kind of the loner with a secret love for his family, and I agree that out of all the characters, he's the most deserving of the hero title. I'm glad you brought up Addie's prophecy about Jewel because I've thought it was so interesting that she had trust in Jewel when no one else did, and you represented that well! Also, the point you made about Jewel's character progression is so interesting!

    ReplyDelete

As I Lay Dying, I Need A Hero!!

  For our final Hero’s Journey blog post I wanted to use prompt 3, thus arguing for the validity of one of the characters being the “Hero”...